Greek leader’s referendum bombshell

Greek austerity

Greeks protest against austerity measures in June. The country could now have a chance to vote on the EU rescue, and its associated conditions. Photograph: Lefteris Pitarakis/AP

In the ever surprising, ever ongoing saga that is Europe’s debt crisis, few expected it would be a referendum, announced by the country at the centre of the storm, that would supplant all the twists and turns of the drama so far.

But when MPs of Greece’s ruling Pasok party gathered in the Athens parliament and heard the announcement by George Papandreou, many could scarcely believe their ears. They thought the prime minister would wax lyrical about Greece’s luck in being resuscitated from near economic collapse by last week’s decision by the EU and the IMF to write off half of Greece’s debt and prop it up with further aid.

Instead, Papandreou, in an act of unprecedented brinkmanship, upped the ante. The deal clinched at the marathon European summit when banks bowed to an ultimatum by Chancellor Angela Merkel, would, Papandreou said, be put to popular vote; for all the doubters who had met the deal with disdain, there was a simple answer: let the people speak.

“Citizens are the source of our strength. Citizens will be called upon to say a big ‘yes’ or a big ‘no’ to the new loan arrangement. This is a supreme act of democracy and of patriotism for the people to make their own decision … we’ve faith in the people. We believe in democratic participation. We’re not afraid of it,” he said.

With his two-year-old government’s popularity at its lowest ever in the wake of relentless austerity, Papandreou clearly hopes that the referendum, expected in January, will allow voters to let off steam.

Hostility to Pasok MPs over wage, pension and benefit cuts is such that many daren’t be seen in public. “We can’t even leave our homes to go to a taverna any more,” said one, insisting on anonymity. “You’re called a pig or a traitor for passing measures none of us wanted to pass. It’s not a life.”

On Friday, Greece’s octogenarian Pasok president, Carolos Papoulias, joined those booed when protests prevented a parade commemorating Greece’s entry on the allied side in the second world war.

But with so much resting on the deal, it is unclear whether Greece’s international creditors see the referendum the same way. Haris Kastinides, the interior minister, said that if the referendum was rejected the bailout accord would “obviously” not be enforced.

Eurozone states spent months over the agreement, which will see private banks and insurers accepting a voluntary 50% loss on Greek government bond holdings – now seen as vital if Athens is to stave off default. As the second bailout for Greece since it was rescued with €110bn in May 2010, Merkel and other leaders had a tough time selling it to their countries and bankers. Within hours of the deal, the French president, Nicolas Sarkozy, conceded it was “an error” that Greece, which clearly cooked the books, was allowed in the eurozone. After the Papandreou announcement the Dow Jones dropped 221.75 points, or 1.81%, to 12,009.36. “This is just the latest twist in the unfolding tragedy,” said Sony Kapoor of London thinktank Re-Define. “With an irresponsible opposition that is promising Greek voters the moon, it’s very difficult to see how this referendum could be won under the gut-wrenching austerity.”

And there was an angry reception from some people in Athens for the referendum, the first since the collapse of military rule in 1974. Across the board, politicians denounced a “dirty trick” to avoid early elections. Many expressed disbelief the prime minister had remembered to put the country’s fate “in the hands of the people” after ignoring protests over austerity for two years.

“This is absolutely insane,” Antonis Samaras, the conservative opposition leader told the Guardian. “The man is trying to stay in power at any cost … posing the dilemma that Greeks either vote for him to stay in power or they forget Europe … for Greeks to be in Europe is a long-standing strategic position, and he is putting it in jeopardy. We will do whatever it takes to stop such a development.”

Top conservatives did not rule out MPs from Samaras’ New Democracy party resigning en masse, forcing elections.

Evangelos Venizelos – the finance minister who is also a law professor and Greece’s most talented politician – said the referendum was precisely because the opposition were so unsupportive in negotiations with eurozone members. New Democracy has repeatedly called for Greece’s bailout terms to be improved arguing that last week’s deal will condemn the country to even more austerity and deeper recession. “Greece is living through a drama from which it must be released by asking the people to express its will,” he told parliament.

“Do Greeks want to remain in Europe, in the eurozone with the euro in a country that belongs to the developed world, or do they want to return to the 1960s? Do they think it is good to owe €100bn to the banks, or do they not think it’s good to live with such debt? Each citizen will make their own decision, with responsibility, in a process that’ll give a national sense of relief and recovery.”

Source: http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2011/nov/01/greek-leader-referendum-bombshell?newsfeed=true

Share

Papandreou Seeks Support in Referendum, Raising Default Risk

Greek Prime Minister George Papandreou called a referendum and a parliamentary confidence vote, raising the prospect of derailing Europe’s bailout effort and pushing Greece into default. Stocks and the euro tumbled.

Papandreou’s gambit risks pushing the country into default if rejected by voters, and raises the ante with dissidents in his own party. Papandreou’s popularity has plunged after a raft of austerity measures cut pensions and wages, increased taxes and sparked a wave of social unrest. An opinion poll published Oct. 29 showed most Greeks believe the accord on a new bailout package and a debt writedown is negative.

“Papandreou could lose the referendum, which means that new elections would have to be called,” Thomas Costerg, European economist at Standard Chartered Bank in London, said in an e-mail. “Heightened Greek uncertainty could propagate to other fragile euro-area countries, in particular Italy.”

German bunds jumped, sending yields down the most since March 2009, and the euro weakened while stocks and U.S. futures fell. German 10-year yields slipped 17 basis points to 1.85 percent at 10 a.m. in London. Italian bonds dropped, pushing the 10-year yield to as much as 440 basis points above benchmark German bunds, a euro-era record. The euro was 1 percent lower at $1.3718 after yesterday’s 2 percent decline.

The MSCI All-Country World Index retreated 1.6 percent and Standard & Poor’s 500 Index futures lost 1.4 percent. The Athens benchmark general index sank 6.2 percent to 758.46 at 12:10 p.m. in Athens.

‘Consequential’ Move

Pacific Investment Management Co. Chief Executive Officer Mohamed El-Erian said the referendum call “is material and consequential.”

“In addition to constituting a major political gamble, the run-up will put the European Central Bank, EU and International Monetary Fund in a tough position regarding disbursements to Greece,” El-Erian said in an e-mail today. He also expressed concern that the European Union deal “appears to be unraveling from many sides.”

Most of the 1,009 people surveyed on Oct. 27, the day the agreement was announced, said the accord should be put to a referendum, according to the results of the Kapa Research SA poll, published in To Vima newspaper. Forty-six percent said they’d oppose the plan at such a referendum. In the same poll, more than seven in 10 favored Greece remaining in the euro.

Confidence Vote

The referendum will likely be held after details of the EU accord are wound up, Papandreou said. The vote of confidence in Parliament will begin tomorrow and conclude late on Nov. 4, according to statements yesterday by House Speaker Filipos Petsalnikos.

“For the new agreement, we must go to a referendum for Greeks to decide,” Papandreou told lawmakers of his ruling socialist Pasok party in statements carried live yesterday from Athens on state-run Vouli TV. “Democracy is alive and well and Greeks are being called to rise to a national duty beyond the regular electoral processes.”

EU leaders carved out a second aid package for Greece at a summit in Brussels lasting into the early hours of Oct. 27, after Papandreou scraped together parliamentary approval for the second round of austerity measures in four months. Greece will receive 130 billion euros ($180 billion) in public funds plus a 50 percent writedown on Greek debt, following a fully taxpayer- funded package of 110 billion euros extended in May 2010.

Blindsided

The decision to call a referendum on the five-day-old bailout blindsided Greece’s European partners and placed another hurdle in the way of efforts to staunch the debt crisis, German coalition lawmakers said.

The announcement came “out of the blue, it’s surprising, very risky,” Norbert Barthle, the ranking member of Merkel’s Christian Democratic Union party on parliament’s budget committee, said by phone today. French President Nicolas Sarkozy is “dismayed” by the Greek plan, Le Monde newspaper reported, citing unnamed people close to Sarkozy.

At least three Pasok lawmakers have voiced concerns over Papandreou’s moves yesterday, with one, Dimitris Lintzeris, calling for a national salvation government in an open letter to Papandreou. Another deputy, Kostas Kartalis, asked for a meeting of ruling party lawmakers to be held as soon as possible.

“I can no longer look at polls where the majority is against the agreement, the majority is against the program, but a majority is also in favor of staying in the euro,” Finance Minister Evangelos Venizelos said on Antenna TV after Papandreou announced his decision. A “no” vote at the referendum would lead to “developments” that the government would assess, Venizelos said.

Stomach Pains

Venizelos was admitted to an Athens hospital with stomach pains early today and is expected to remain in the clinic until later in the day, according to an e-mailed statement from the Athens-based Finance Ministry.

Papandreou, whose term ends in 2013, is seeking renewed support to push through measures including job cuts to turn around an economy that is set to shrink 5.5 percent this year. The program involves new taxes and cuts in spending to plug the EU’s second-biggest budget gap.

The state budget deficit widened to 19.2 billion euros in the January to end-September period from 16.7 billion euros a year earlier, according to an e-mailed statement from the Athens-based Finance Ministry yesterday.

‘Reckless’

Opposition parties repeated their call for elections. Papandreou’s plans are “reckless” and put Greece’s EU membership at risk, lead opposition New Democracy party spokesman Yiannis Michelakis said.

Papandreou “has tossed Greece’s future in Europe in the air like a coin,” Michelakis said in an e-mailed statement from ND’s Athens offices yesterday. “He is dangerous and must go. There is a solution: elections now. It’s the safest ‘referendum.’”

New Democracy leader Antonis Samaras told President Karolos Papoulias today in Athens that “we have a historic responsibility to do what is necessary so that the future of the country and Europe is not placed at risk.” He told reporters afterwards that elections are a “national imperative.”

Papandreou now has just a three-seat majority in parliament and won approval for his latest austerity package amid protests that left one person dead. The budget measures prompted a near- rebellion in Papandreou’s party and violence in the streets.

The New Democracy party would win 22 percent of the vote in elections, with Papandreou’s Pasok party receiving 14.7 percent, and neither getting enough to form a majority in parliament, according to the Kapa poll. More than 26 percent of voters said they were undecided on who to back. The margin of error is 3.09 percentage points.

Not Binding

Separately, the International Swaps and Derivatives Association said that the euro-area proposals for Greek bonds appear to involve “a voluntary exchange that would not be binding on all holders,” according to an e-mailed statement.

“As such, it does not appear to be likely that the euro zone proposal will trigger payments under existing CDS contracts,” the statement said. “However, whether or not it does so will be decided by the Determinations Committee on the basis of specific facts, if a request is made to them.”

The ISDA statement late yesterday follows a review of whether the proposal would constitute a “credit event” for holders of credit-default swaps linked to the securities.

Source: http://www.businessweek.com/news/2011-11-01/papandreou-seeks-support-in-referendum-raising-default-risk.html

Share